Home > Uncategorized > Common Core opponents jump the shark

Common Core opponents jump the shark

March 31, 2014

The test results are in: Knee-jerk opponents of Common Core are NOT smarter than a fifth grader.

The latest bogus example to gin up fake outrage comes from an anti-CCSS website called whatiscommoncore. A Utah high school student captured screenshots of the SAGE test, showing somewhat philosophical resource material for the essay question, which was about the nature and value of books. Follow the link to view the screenshots.

The question presents some reading material on the value of books, making a sort of modest proposal that books are static narratives that do not engage the reader, compared with narratives like video games that involve the reader. The essay questions then invite the student to write on that prompt, either supporting or refuting the argument. This is in the best pedagogical tradition of rhetoric, by making the student support or refute an argument on a provocative topic.

The author says right in the text “It should probably go without saying that I don’t agree with this argument.” That’s in the screenshot.

But the opponents’ claim, of course, is that CCSS is “anti-book” and teaches the value of video games over books. I am laughing out loud at the sheer willful idiocy of it all. Here’s what they say:

Utah High School Student Captures Screen Shots of the Anti-Book Common Core Test

A Utah High School student took the Common Core (SAGE) test this week. Seeing objectionable issues in that test, she thought her mother should know. The student took screen shots using her cell phone and sent them to her mother. Her mother passed them along to us.

The message given in this test is that book literacy is inferior to the playing of video games. The test claims that literature forces passivity but video games teach students how to be leaders. Long live grunts and smoke signals.

The test makes these following devilish assertions: “books understimulate the senses” and “books are downright discriminatory” and books are “choreographed by another person [while video games are not]“. These are mean pushes toward valuing video gaming instead of books and they precisely match the pushy philosophy of Common Core creator-turned College Board President David Coleman. They also match the philosophy of Microsoft Owner/ Common Core funder Bill Gates. So it is no surprise. It’s still sickening.

I am reminded of Tea Party rallies featuring OBAMA=HITLER signs and demanding “Government, hands off my Medicare!”

It is the same idiocy that claims “Huckleberry Finn” is racist – or that “Brave New World” advocates sexual libertinism.

The worst part is, it just might work.

  1. March 31, 2014 at 11:21 am

    Ok you found one claim. I saw that Saturday and cringed. Yet the DOE and administration makes one cringe 10 times a day with their statements not based on fact either. … I know those above who jumped the shark and know they did so without being fully briefed or taking the time to look over the entire data. … Plus I know that is something every parent has done in their lifetime when dealing with our own children, especially when they become teenagers….

    However a retraction is supposed to be coming shortly, and we move on. The real fact is that the implementation (further defined as a hat-tip to you) of Common Core is very damaging to children. And the sad thing about politics is, that sometimes the most ridiculous of accusations, tend to move the cause the greatest distance… I wish it wasn’t so… but in conflict, one uses whatever tool is available… like the raid on Dieppe, this one shall be chalked up to a lesson learned.

  2. John Young
    March 31, 2014 at 1:01 pm

    Knee Jerk supporters are also livng a common core lie. Which is worse?

    I notice knee jerk is n your narrative, but not your title.

  3. John Young
    March 31, 2014 at 1:47 pm

    CCSS implementation is destroying its own intrinsic value, high standards.

  1. March 31, 2014 at 9:33 pm
Comments are closed.
%d bloggers like this: